These are simply metal stars from Michael's that I covered with scrapbooking paper using mod podge.
But don't bother rushing out to Michael's for the stars. I haven't been able to find them anymore for the last couple of years. I just happened to uncover these stashed away in my craft cabinet. I had six small stars and three large ones.
I decided this last star was a little plain so I found this candle garland at Michael's to spice it up just a little. I really like that addition.
These stars are available in my etsy shop.